A month or so back members of the Wordsmiths shared their favourite poems with the group. As an occasional feature we will publish their individual pieces, this one is by Val Chapman.
Not so much a song but more a poem
There wasn’t one particular poem that I could claim to be a favourite, so I decided to do a bit of research and still couldn’t come up with one that I enjoyed above all others.
It was when I was singing along to myself, as I do, that it occurred to me that songs were, for the most part, poems, set to music.
As I am one of those boring people who like their poetry to rhyme, otherwise it’s prose, this naturally opened up a lot more availability, which I am not altogether sure was a good thing, as I am hopeless at making decisions.
However, these two struck a chord (if you pardon the pun) for different reasons.
“It would never have worked,” I like as it seems to be taking the reader down one path, then veering off down another unexpected one, and finally, down yet another.
“Love song,” I can barely get through without a lump in my throat. I am sure this resonates with so many of our, though perhaps more so, the previous generations when feelings were often hard to express.
— Just a quick note, I don’t know whether it is just a northern expression, but the words “I was tight” indicates a somewhat over-enjoyment of an alcoholic nature! —–
This one in particular came as a bit of a surprise, as they were both written by the same very talented writer, known more for her humour, and this poem is an unexpected offering from her I think.
They were written in 1978 (love song)
1987 (It would never have worked)
By the wonderful Victoria Wood.
Victoria Wood (Photo Credit Wikipedia)
IT WOULD NEVER HAVE WORKED
It’s over,
We missed the bus,
Nice idea, but not for us,
We didn’t click, let’s make it quick and say goodbye,
Don’t hold my hand,
And don’t demand a reason why.
No loving looks, no fond regards,
Tonight was always on the cards.
I wanted champagne and roses, ’cause that’s the way I am,
You gave me vimto,
Tinned carrots,
And spam.
I wanted love to come and knock our blocks off,
But even Venus takes her cards and clocks off.
Your idea of foreplay was to take your socks off.
Things would never have worked
Rapport is a thing you just can’t manufacture,
You had your pin up girl, I couldn’t match her,
I didn’t want to, it was Margaret Thatcher.
Things would never have worked.
I wanted moonlight, romance and all that silly tosh,
You wanted gerbils,
A whippet,
A wash.
I wanted love songs but you wouldn’t write them,
My earlobe nibbled, but you wouldn’t bite them,
You’d only fart and then attempt to light them,
Things would never have worked.
We’re not compatible, let’s not get blue here,
At least we see each other’s point of view dear,
I like big, hunky men and so do you dear,
Things would never have worked.
LOVE SONG
Made your breakfast this morning,
Like any old day,
Then I remembered and I threw it away
I found an old photo,
In a kitchen drawer.
You by the seaside, during the war.
You were laughing at something,
With the wind in your hair,
You were ever so slim then, and your hair was still fair.
And I wanted to kiss you,
But you always laughed,
And I wanted to tell you,
But I felt daft.
Still, we got married,
I was tight,
We both got embarrassed, played rummy all night
I remember the baby, and it’s sticky out ears,
But I can’t single out things,
Over the years.
On Woman’s surgical, sat by your bed,
I knew that I loved you,
But I never said.
I brought you Black Magic,
And they said you’d died,
I had a cup of tea there,
Came home and cried.
Got to go back to the hospital to collect your things,
Your nightie, your glasses, your wedding ring
Made your breakfast this morning,
Like any old day,
Then I remembered and I threw it away.
Thank you Val, I find that every time I read Love Song I get something in my eyes.
Wasn’t she brilliant?
Of course songs are poems (only not so much some of the newer ones.)
Leonard Cohen was a poet who couldn’t sell his poems so he took up the guitar (you can tell from his voice…).
But Victoria Wood was a one-off
LikeLiked by 2 people
I am particularly moved by Love Song. It has the same effect on me every time I read it, so simple so poignant.
LikeLike